Claude Code loops vs Codex loops.
Same idea, different vendor, same way of going wrong.
Published May 12, 2026 · 6 min read
Anthropic ships Claude Code. OpenAI ships Codex. Both are looping agents — both run an observe-plan-act-verify cycle until something tells them to stop. People ask us all the time: which one is “safer”? The honest answer is: neither. The vendor doesn’t fix the loop problem. The runtime around it does.
How a Claude Code loop fails
Claude Code is good at long-horizon reasoning, which is also why it’s expensive when it goes wrong. A typical Claude loop failure looks like this: it picks a wrong-but-plausible explanation early, then spends 40 minutes building consistent logic on top of that bad assumption. Reasoning tokens stack up. The bill keeps going. Then it confidently announces it’s done.
That’s a hallucinated completion. The agent thinks the test passed because it convinced itself the test was wrong. Without an external verifier, you can’t tell.
How a Codex loop fails
Codex tends to fail faster and louder. The classic failure is infinite retry — same patch, same diff, same broken test, on repeat. Cheaper per attempt, more attempts, similar bill at the end.
We named these in our 13-class failure taxonomy. They’re not edge cases — they’re the bulk of what shows up in real run logs.
The fix is the same for both
Three things, regardless of vendor:
- Hard budget. Not a soft warning — a runtime cap that kills the next attempt before it goes out.
- External verifier. The agent doesn’t get to mark its own homework.
--verify “pnpm test”does. - An audit log. One line per attempt, on disk, in a format you can grep or replay later.
One command, both vendors
# Claude Code, Codex, Gemini — pick whichever martin run "fix the auth regression" --budget-usd 3 --verify "pnpm test"
MartinLoop is provider-agnostic. Same flags, same governance, whichever vendor you’re paying. Drives Claude Code, Codex, Gemini agents, custom LangGraph — same primitives every time.
Prefer to drive it from your editor instead of the terminal? See the MCP server for Claude Desktop, Gemini & Cline.